| CHSAA / Private | ||||||||||||
| HOME | ||||||||||||
| Top Teams | Top Players | |||||||||||
| Team | Year | W | L | Accomplishment | Player | School | Hgt | Year | College | |||
| Stepinac | 1951 | 23 | 3 | NY State Catholic Champs | Marty Conlon | Stepinac | 6-8 | 1986 | Providence / Milwaukee | |||
| Stepinac | 1960 | 23 | 2 | State CHSAA Champs | John Falconi | Iona Prep | 6-5 | 1970 | Davidson /Buffalo | |||
| Stepinac | 1991 | 24 | 4 | State CHSAA B Champs | Eric Mobley | Salesian | 6-10 | 1989 | Pitt / Memphis | |||
| Stepinac | 1986 | 20 | 7 | State CHSAA A Semifinals | Art White | Stepinac | 6-5 | 1968 | Georgetown / Milwaukee | |||
| Stepinac | 1985 | 18 | 7 | State CHSAA A Quarterfinals | Steve Masiello | Harvey | 6-2 | 1996 | Kentucky | |||
| Stepinac | 1993 | 21 | 6 | State CHSAA B Semifinals | George Dalzell | Hackley | 6-3 | 1963 | Colgate | |||
| Stepinac | 1982 | 18 | 7 | Fred Quartlebaum | Stepinac | 6-3 | 1985 | Fordham | ||||
| Stepinac | 1994 | 22 | 2 | Danya Abrams | Hackley | 6-8 | 1993 | Boston College | ||||
| Horst Kluger | Blessed Sacrament | 6-5 | 1950 | Villanova | ||||||||
| Salesian | 1989 | 24 | 3 | State CHSAA B Semifinals | Dick Wise | Stepinac | 6-9 | 1951 | Notre Dame | |||
| Salesian | 1997 | 25 | 2 | State CHSAA C Champs | Dick McDine | Stepinac | G | 1952 | St John's | |||
| Salesian | 1976 | 24 | 3 | Dick Elston | Stepinac | C | 1952 | Providence | ||||
| Salesian | 1998 | 23 | 2 | State CHSAA C Runnerup | Ed Bugniazet | Iona Prep | 6-0 | 1953 | Fordham | |||
| Salesian | 1999 | 22 | 5 | State CHSAA C Champs | John Ritch | Stepinac | 6-6 | 1953 | USMA | |||
| Salesian | 1993 | 12 | 12 | State CHSAA C Runnerup | Dick Carroll | Stepinac | 6-1 | 1954 | Manhattan | |||
| Dennis Noschese | Stepinac | 6-4 | 1954 | Holy Cross | ||||||||
| Sacred Heart | 1994 | 15 | 11 | State CHSAA C Champs | Ed Frampton | Iona Prep | 6-1 | 1954 | Georgetown | |||
| Sacred Heart | 1988 | 19 | 9 | State CHSAA C Runnerup | Ray Vales | Iona Prep | 6-1 | 1957 | Notre Dame | |||
| Sacred Heart | 1960 | 18 | 2 | Dale Comey | NYMA | 5-9 | 1959 | UConn | ||||
| Tim Cohane | Stepinac | 6-2 | 1960 | Navy | ||||||||
| Iona Prep | 1998 | 17 | 8 | State CHSAA B Semifinals | Frank Richichi | Stepinac | 6-5 | 1960 | Boston College | |||
| Iona Prep | 1962 | 15 | 6 | Mike Ansbro | Stepinac | 6-1 | 1960 | Iona | ||||
| Iona Prep | 1990 | 16 | 8 | Ed Dealy | Stepinac | G | 1960 | Cornell | ||||
| Larry Dick | Stepinac | F | 1960 | Seton Hall | ||||||||
| Hackley | 1993 | 23 | 6 | State Private C Champs | Joe Zamborsky | Sacred Heart | 6-1 | 1960 | Manhattan | |||
| Hackley | 1963 | 15 | 4 | WPPSAA Champs | Pete Gaudet | Iona Prep | 6-0 | 1960 | Boston U | |||
| John Mastropolo | Stepinac | 5-8 | 1961 | Boston College | ||||||||
| Rye CDS | 1983 | 23 | 0 | Peter Kaufmann | Stepinac | 6-0 | 1961 | Dayton | ||||
| Irving School (Tarrytown) | 1950 | 17 | 1 | Joe Vales | Iona Prep | 6-2 | 1963 | Notre Dame | ||||
| Ken LaPolla | Iona Prep | 6-2 | 1963 | Iona | ||||||||
| Walt Speth | Sacred Heart | 5-11 | 1963 | Notre Dame | ||||||||
| John Purcell | Stepinac | 6-4 | 1964 | Navy | ||||||||
| Dick Licini | Iona Prep | 6-4 | 1965 | Houston Astros | ||||||||
| Frank Magaletta | Stepinac | 6-4 | 1966 | Fairfield | ||||||||
| Bill McGuggins | Blessed Sacrament | 6-6 | 1966 | Iona | ||||||||
| John Borgia | Iona Prep | 6-0 | 1966 | Princeton | ||||||||
| Tom Purcell | Stepinac | 6-5 | 1967 | Fairfield | ||||||||
| Jerry Couzens | Sacred Heart | 6-7 | 1968 | Princeton | ||||||||
| Mike Kayser | Stepinac | 6-4 | 1970 | Syracuse | ||||||||
| Ron McGuggins | Blessed Sacrament | 6-7 | 1971 | St John's | ||||||||
| Lou Brignone | Salesian | 5-10 | 1971 | LIU | ||||||||
| Vince Kehayas | Salesian | 6-6 | 1972 | St Francis | ||||||||
| John Griff | Stepinac | 6-4 | 1973 | Fordham | ||||||||
| Kevin Doherty | Stepinac | 6-3 | 1974 | Davidson | ||||||||
| Bill Harrington | Iona Prep | 6-1 | 1975 | William & Mary | ||||||||
| Ted O'Gorman | Stepinac | 6-7 | 1976 | William & Mary | ||||||||
| Joe Breen | Salesian | 6-2 | 1976 | Brown | ||||||||
| Larry Blucher | Stepinac | 6-8 | 1981 | UConn | ||||||||
| Tom Foley | Iona Prep | 6-2 | 1981 | Iona | ||||||||
| Tim O'Toole | Stepinac | 6-3 | 1982 | Fairfield | ||||||||
| Brendan Potter | Stepinac | 6-3 | 1982 | Fairfield | ||||||||
| Chris O'Gorman | Stepinac | 6-6 | 1982 | Iona | ||||||||
| Brian Martin | Stepinac | G | 1983 | FDU | ||||||||
| Tom Parrotta | Stepinac | 6-5 | 1984 | Fordham | ||||||||
| Steve Breen | Stepinac | 6-9 | 1986 | Fordham | ||||||||
| Kyle Harrington | Stepinac | 6-2 | 1988 | Princeton | ||||||||
| Billy Palagonia | Stepinac | G | 1990 | Gardner-Webb | ||||||||
| Anthony Dixon | Salesian | F | 1990 | Duquesne | ||||||||
| Sander Saljanin | Iona Prep | 6-6 | 1990 | Iona | ||||||||
| David Conlon | Stepinac | 6-6 | 1991 | Vermont | ||||||||
| Jarrod Smith | Stepinac | 6-10 | 1991 | Morgan St | ||||||||
| Kevin O'Keeffe | Stepinac | 6-2 | 1991 | Manhattan | ||||||||
| Trevor Cheng-Leung | Stepinac | 6-3 | 1991 | Marist | ||||||||
| Chris Watson | Stepinac | 6-7 | 1993 | Niagara | ||||||||
| Tyrone Foster | Harvey | 6-1 | 1993 | Western Wyoming | ||||||||
| Terrance Burks | Stepinac | 6-4 | 1995 | Columbia | ||||||||
| Corey Vandiver | Hackley | 6-2 | 1995 | Brown | ||||||||
| Elijah Haskins | Stepinac | 6-1 | 1996 | Wagner | ||||||||
| Peter Shea | Iona Prep | 6-7 | 1996 | Iona | ||||||||
| Jeremy Logan | Salesian | 6-5 | 1997 | Fairfield | ||||||||
| Antoine Orr | Salesian | 5-9 | 1997 | St Peter's | ||||||||
| Jared Johnson | Salesian | 6-4 | 1998 | Manhattan | ||||||||
| Justin Jackette | Iona Prep | 6-2 | 1998 | Manhattan | ||||||||
| Kyle Walsh | Stepinac | 6-2 | 1998 | Fairfield | ||||||||
| Nick Delfico | Iona Prep | 6-5 | 1999 | Fairfield | ||||||||