| CHSAA Private 1965 | |||||||||||
| Teams | All County | ||||||||||
| School | W | L | Class | Sect | Accomplishements | Player | School | Hgt | Class | College | |
| Iona Prep | 13 | 6 | CHSAA | Don Fanning | Stepinac | F | Sr | Niagara | |||
| Sacred Heart | 7 | 11 | CHSAA | Dick Licini | Iona Prep | 6-4 | Sr | Baseball Houston Astros | |||
| Concordia Prep | 4 | 11 | CHSAA | ||||||||
| Stepinac | 3 | 14 | CHSAA | Bob Caputo | Iona Prep | 6-2 | Sr | ||||
| Bill Hart | Sacred Hart | F | Sr | ||||||||
| Salesian | CHSAA | ||||||||||
| Blessed Sacrament | CHSAA | Chris Speciale | Salesian | 6-6 | Jr | Transferred as a Senior | |||||
| Hackley | Private | Bill McGuggins | Blessed Sacrament | 6-3 | Jr | ||||||
| NYSD | Private | Frank Magaletta | Stepinac | 6-3 | Jr | ||||||
| Peekskill MA | Private | ||||||||||
| Children's Village | Private | ||||||||||
| St Peter's Peekskill | CHSAA | ||||||||||
| Scarborough | Private | ||||||||||
| Rye CDS | Private | ||||||||||
| Cedar Knolls | Private | ||||||||||