| CHSAA Private 1974 | |||||||||||
| Teams | All County | ||||||||||
| School | W | L | Class | Sect | Accomplishements | Player | School | Hgt | Class | College | |
| Stepinac | 12 | 11 | A | CHSAA | Sect 1 A Semifinals | Kevin Doherty | Stepinac | 6-3 | Sr | Davidson | |
| Cedar Knolls | 17 | 2 | Private | Kevin Keane | Stepinac | 6-2 | Sr | Albany | |||
| Halsted | 14 | 3 | Private | ||||||||
| Rye CDS | 11 | 7 | Private | Craig Speilman | Salesian | Sr | |||||
| Iona Prep | 8 | 13 | CHSAA | Bernie Blaney | Iona Prep | Sr | |||||
| Sacred Heart | 7 | 13 | CHSAA | Bob Hamilton | Iona Prep | Sr | |||||
| NYSD | 4 | 17 | Private | Andy Sikora | Halsted | 6-4 | Sr | ||||
| Greg Proctor | Cedar Knolls | 6-8 | Sr | ||||||||
| Salesian | CHSAA | Jeff Austin | Sacred Heart | 6-2 | Sr | ||||||
| Blessed Sacrament | CHSAA | ||||||||||
| Hackley | Private | Bill Kohlenbeck | Blessed Sacrament | Jr | |||||||
| Scarborough | Private | Bill Gargano | Halsted | 5-10 | Soph | ||||||
| Franciscan | CHSAA | Tony Salvo | Stepinac | 6-3 | Jr | 1000 Point Scorer / Appalachian St | |||||
| Peekskill MA | Private | Cliff Coffyn | Stepinac | G | Jr | FDU | |||||
| St Peter's Peekskill | CHSAA | Larry Taglia | Stepinac | F | Jr | Pace | |||||
| Children's Village | Private | Bill Harrington | Iona Prep | 6-0 | Jr | William & Mary | |||||