| Orange County 1951 | |||||||||||
| Teams | All County | ||||||||||
| School | W | L | Class | Sect | Accomplishements | Player | School | Hgt | Class | College | |
| Newburgh FA | 17 | 4 | A | 9 | Section 9 A Champs | Ed O'Connor | St Patrick's | 6-7 | 1951 | Manhattan | |
| Cornwall | 17 | 5 | C | 9 | Section 9 C Semis / OCL Champs | Joe Bayno | SS Seward | F | Sr | ||
| St Patrick's (Newburgh) | 15 | 3 | CHSAA | ||||||||
| SS Seward | 11 | 6 | D | 9 | Section 9 D Semis / OCL Consolation Champs | Ed Gabron | Newburgh FA | C | Sr | ||
| Middletown | 8 | 9 | A | 9 | Section 9 A Semifinals | Matt Chrystal | Newburgh FA | F | Sr | ||
| Pine Bush | C | 9 | OCL Runnerup | Bob Brown | Middletown | C | Sr | ||||
| Highland Falls | C | 9 | OCL Semifinals | Andy "Ace" Meyers | Warwick | C | Sr | ||||
| Montgomery | D | 9 | OCL Consolation Runnerup | Paul Cabrinety | Tuxedo | C | Sr | ||||
| Warwick | C | 9 | OCL Consolation Semifinals | Jerry Jacobowitz | Walden | G | Sr | ||||
| Maybrook | D | 9 | Scott Templeton | Cornwall | C | Sr | |||||
| Tuxedo | D | 9 | Ed LaForge | Pine Bush | F | Sr | |||||
| Chester | D | 9 | Lincoln Litchfield | Montgomery | F | Sr | |||||
| Goshen | 9 | ||||||||||
| Walden | 9 | John Grover | Pine Bush | C | Jr | ||||||
| Washingtonville | 9 | Bob Habig | Pt Jervis | G | Jr | ||||||
| Monroe | 9 | Bill Parry | Middletown | F | Jr | ||||||
| Cornwall-on-Hudson | 9 | Duane Bruen | Goshen | G | Jr | ||||||
| Otisville | 9 | Mickey McMahon | Cornwall | G | Jr | ||||||
| Central Valley | 9 | Richard McGinnis | Chester | G | Jr | ||||||
| Pt Jervis | 1 | 15 | 9 | David Bloodgood | Central Valley | C | Jr | ||||
| Joe Dillon | Highland Falls | C | Soph | ||||||||