| Orange County 1986 | |||||||||||
| Teams | All County | ||||||||||
| School | W | L | Class | Sect | Accomplishements | Player | School | Hgt | Class | College | |
| James I. O'Neill | 23 | 2 | C | 9 | State C Runnerup | Andre McClendon | O'Neill | 6-0 | Sr | 1000 point scorer / Fordham | |
| Monroe-Woodbury | 19 | 3 | A | 9 | Section 9 A Champs | Dwayne Israel | Sugar Loaf | 6-4 | Sr | 1000 point scorer | |
| Goshen | 17 | 4 | B | 9 | Section 9 B Semifinals | ||||||
| Middletown | 14 | 5 | A | 9 | Section 9 A Semifinals | Don Feldman | O'Neill | 6-5 | Sr | ||
| Sugar Loaf | 13 | 8 | D | 9 | Section 9 D Runnerup | Keith Rhodes | O'Neill | 6-2 | Sr | ||
| Chester | 12 | 10 | C | 9 | Section 9 C Semifinals | Rob Smith | Monroe-Woodbury | 5-11 | Sr | ||
| Burke Catholic | 11 | 10 | B | 9 | Steve Malvey | Monroe-Woodbury | 6-4 | Sr | |||
| Minnisink Valley | 11 | 10 | B | 9 | Donnell Smallwood | Sugar Loaf | 6-2 | Sr | |||
| Valley Central | 9 | 11 | A | 9 | Section 9 A Runnerup | Mark Jessup | Goshen | 6-2 | Sr | ||
| Cornwall | 6 | 14 | 9 | Dwayne Robinson | NFA | 6-3 | Sr | Short season | |||
| Newburgh FA | 5 | 14 | 1 | Michael Gaddy | NFA | 5-9 | Sr | Short season | |||
| Pine Bush | 3 | 15 | 9 | Alex McClearn | Valley Central | 6-3 | Sr | ||||
| Washingtonville | 3 | 15 | 9 | Alex Manning | NYMA | 6-1 | Sr | ||||
| Tuxedo | 9 | Eric Phillips | NYMA | 5-10 | Sr | ||||||
| Pt Jervis | 9 | Scott Miller | Warwick | 6-4 | Sr | ||||||
| Warwick | 9 | Elwood Brown | Minisink Valley | F | Sr | ||||||
| NYMA | 9 | Martin Hossan | Minisink Valley | 6-5 | Sr | ||||||
| SS Seward | |||||||||||
| David Bernsley | Monroe-Woodbury | 6-7 | Jr | ||||||||
| Steve Sexton | Monroe-Woodbury | 6-0 | Jr | ||||||||
| Chris Hanley | Chester | 6-4 | Soph | ||||||||
| Damian Brown | Middletown | F | Soph | ||||||||
| Tim Reynolds | Middletown | F | Frosh | ||||||||
| Andy Lake | Burke | 6-2 | Soph | Marist | |||||||