| Player | School | Hgt | Year | College |
| Phil Leibrock | AB Davis | G | 1956 | Ithaca |
| Jon von Bargen | AB Davis | 6-7 | 1957 | Belmont Abbey (coached by Al McGuire) |
| Bob Trupin | AB Davis | 6-0 | 1961 | Yale |
| Ken Ackerman | AB Davis | 6-1 | 1962 | Boston U |
| Rudy Bennett | Mt Vernon | 6-5 | 1965 | NY Tech / ABA Carolina Cougars |
| Ken Singleton | Mt Vernon | 6-4 | 1965 | Baseball NY Mets |
| Bill Pleas | Mt Vernon | 6-3 | 1967 | LaSalle |
| Barry Rothstein | Mt Vernon | 5-10 | 1969 | Springfield |
| Gus Williams | Mt Vernon | 6-3 | 1971 | USC / Seattle NBA |
| Rudy Hackett | Mt Vernon | 6-7 | 1971 | Syracuse / St Louis ABA |
| Mike Young | Mt Vernon | 6-6 | 1971 | Manhattan |
| Ivo Holland | Mt Vernon | 6-3 | 1971 | Boston College |
| Earl Tatum | Mt Vernon | 6-4 | 1972 | Marquette / LA Lakers |
| Ray Williams | Mt Vernon | 6-2 | 1973 | Minnesota / NY Knicks |
| Sam Williams | Mt Vernon | 5-10 | 1974 | San Francisco |
| Lowes Moore | Mt Vernon | 6-1 | 1976 | West Virginia / NBA Clippers |
| Scooter McCray | Mt Vernon | 6-8 | 1978 | Louisville / NBA Cleveland |
| Rodney McCray | Mt Vernon | 6-7 | 1979 | Louisville / NBA Houston |
| Bugeye Gibbs | Mt Vernon | 5-10 | 1979 | Wichita St |
| Curtis Moore | Mt Vernon | 6-2 | 1981 | Nebraska / Portland NBA |
| Ricky Burton | Mt Vernon | 6-4 | 1981 | Seton Hall |
| Donald Russell | Mt Vernon | 6-0 | 1981 | UMass |
| Lewis Hill | Mt Vernon | 6-3 | 1983 | Wichita St |
| Peter Runge | Mt Vernon | 6-7 | 1986 | Manhattan |
| Clive Anderson | Mt Vernon | 6-8 | 1988 | FDU |
| Dean Marshman | Mt Vernon | 6-2 | 1991 | South Alabama |
| Rasul Salahuddin | Mt Vernon | 6-2 | 1991 | Long Beach St |
| Brian Pritchett | Mt Vernon | 6-4 | 1991 | Adelphi |
| Newton Gayle | Mt Vernon | 6-6 | 1993 | Niagara |
| John McDonald | Mt Vernon | 6-1 | 1994 | Loyola Maryland |
| Collin Watson | Mt Vernon | 6-5 | 1996 | Fordham |
| Joe McCurdy | Mt Vernon | 6-5 | 1996 | Marist |
| Kris Ibezim | Mt Vernon | 6-7 | 1998 | Quinnipiac |
| Tim Rollerson | Mt Vernon | 5-9 | 1999 | St Francis |