| Sullivan County 1958 | |||||||||||
| Teams | All County | ||||||||||
| School | W | L | Class | Sect | Accomplishements | Player | School | Hgt | Class | College | |
| Liberty | 22 | 0 | BCD | 9 | Section 9 BCD Champs | ||||||
| Livingston Manor | 14 | 2 | BCD | 9 | WSL Champs | Kevin Moloney | Liberty | 6-6 | Sr | ||
| Delaware Valley | 15 | 4 | BCD | 9 | John Lawrence | Liberty | 5-5 | Sr | |||
| Jeffersonville | 9 | 5 | 9 | Jack Thompson | Liberty | 5-10 | Sr | ||||
| Monticello | 7 | 11 | 9 | Mike Glick | Monticello | 5-11 | Sr | ||||
| Tri-Valley | 9 | Michael Fischer | Livingston Manor | F | Sr | ||||||
| Roscoe | 9 | Richard Fredenberg | Livingston Manor | G | Sr | ||||||
| Eldred | 9 | Muggs Doetsch | Jeffersonville | G | Sr | ||||||
| Narrowsburgh | 9 | Gordon Comstock | Eldred | G | Sr | ||||||
| Fallsburg FA | 0 | 17 | 9 | ||||||||
| Youngsville (Last Year) | 9 | Josh Gerow | Liberty | 6-4 | Jr | ||||||
| Duke Osterhout | Jeffersonville | F | Jr | ||||||||
| St Joseph Seminary (Callicoon) | Rich Cassara | Eldred | 5-9 | Jr | |||||||