| Sullivan County 1989 | |||||||||||
| Teams | All County | ||||||||||
| School | W | L | Class | Sect | Accomplishements | Player | School | Hgt | Class | College | |
| Monticello | 16 | 6 | B | 9 | Section 9 B Runnerup | Jason Mitterwager | Delaware Valley | 6-1 | Sr | 1000 point scorer / Binghamton Baseball | |
| Fallsburg FA | 15 | 6 | C | 9 | Section 9 C Runnerup | Andy Krutman | Fallsburg FA | 6-7 | Sr | New Paltz St | |
| Liberty | 7 | 13 | 9 | ||||||||
| Roscoe | 9 | WSL Champ | Leon Jarrette | Monticello | F | Sr | |||||
| Eldred | 9 | WSL Runnerup / Sect 9 C Runnerup | Michael Hooks | Fallsburg FA | 6-2 | Sr | |||||
| Delaware Valley | 9 | ||||||||||
| Narrowsburg | 9 | Kevin Anderson | Monticello | C | Jr | ||||||
| Livingston Manor | 9 | Ken Sanders | Monticello | G | Jr | ||||||
| Tri-Valley | 9 | Jermayne Williams | Monticello | 5-11 | Jr | ||||||
| Jeffersonville-Youngsville | 9 | David Bertram | Eldred | 6-3 | Jr | ||||||